Which ST is the better buy? Focus or Fiesta?

Alan
By Alan Cesar
Jul 20, 2023 | Ford, Fiesta ST, Buyer's Guide, Focus ST | Posted in Buyer's Guides , Features | From the Dec. 2013 issue | Never miss an article

Photography by Alan Cesar

[Editor's Note: This article originally appeared in the December 2013 issue of Grassroots Motorsports, back when the Fiesta ST was a brand-new model.]

The hot hatch segment in Europe has always been more fiercely competitive and rife with more options for consumers than in the United States. Facing the market against the likes of the Peugeot 208 GTi, Renault Clio RS and VW Polo GTI makes Europe the best breeding and proving ground for anything in the segment. It’s also where Ford spawned the Fiesta ST, its newest fast compact, which hit the streets of Europe ready to punch hard. 

The ST division–it’s not replacing SVT, but rather living alongside it–has now sent this new party to our shores. It takes a well-optioned B-segment car and adds more of everything. We visited Ann Arbor, Michigan, to drive one of these on the marvelous back roads outside the city–to the chagrin of the locals.

Power is the big news here. In the engine bay, its 1.6-liter, twin-cam engine wears a snail and some extra plumbing. That turbo, an intercooler and direct fuel injection give the little four-pot a meaty 202 ft.-lbs. of torque at 4200 rpm, but it’s not a laggy nightmare. This engine is entertaining in the midrange and has good parking lot manners–though it is more exciting if you keep the revs up.

This package is remarkably complete and thought out; it’s not a simple springs-and-dampers upgrade. The engineers behind this car are clearly enthusiasts, and they speak fondly of the track time put into this car. A new, stiffer rear twist beam complements its stiffer springs and lowered ride height. The front steering knuckles are also ST-specific pieces, redesigned with new geometry to add camber, raise the roll center, increase the steering ratio, and improve feel. 

Twist and Turn

Steering feel, by the way, is a welcome addition. Our B-Spec Fiesta, built on a bare-bones hatch, has a wheel as communicative as a bowl of pudding. We’re glad the company addressed this with the ST, while also adding heft.

[That time we raced in the Pirelli World Challenge series]

Engineers put a premium on making this car very neutral in corners, and they calibrated the torque-vectoring control–essentially a brake-based limited-slip system–to put a premium on rear slip angle. Stability control features a Sport mode, but it can also be switched off completely. The latter makes for entertaining and dramatic clutch dumps.

The torque-vectoring system works well enough, but a mechanical limited-slip differential is still on our wish list. One engineer told us the car could have benefited from one, but it was cut due to cost.

Though firm, the ride is far from punishing. This is an entertaining car to toss, and it’s delightfully neutral. A bit of understeer creeps in only at the very limit of adhesion. Torque steer, surprisingly enough, was not an issue.

Stop and Go

Brakes were never a weak point on the Fiesta. Our B-Spec project car drops speed faster than a thief drops a stolen iPad when the red-and-blues start flashing. Still, with some extra weight and lots more power, the ST got upgrades. 

Ford went to their international parts bin and fitted front calipers from a European B-segment van to increase swept area. The rears may look familiar: They’re discs from the first-generation Focus, modified to mount to the Fiesta ST’s suspension. Base Fiestas get only rear drums.

In the engine bay–generating the energy that the brakes dissipate–is a 1.6-liter Ecoboost four-cylinder. It’s direct-injected and intercooled, which helps it contain its 10:1 compression ratio–down one point from the base car–paired with an astounding 21 pounds of boost. 

Bullying the Little Guys

The Fiesta’s refreshed look for 2014 is in line with the stunning Aston Martin-esque grille previously fitted to the Fusion and Focus. The ST car gets a more aggressive version, as well as side skirts, a rear spoiler, diffuser, and twin-tip exhaust. Two 17-inch wheel choices are available, and surprisingly, they don’t look abnormally large. The size suits the stance.

In the U.S., the speedy subcompact market has been lightly occupied for quite some time. The MINI Cooper S was just about the only car in the segment until the recent introduction of the Fiat 500 Abarth. 

That’s part of what makes the Fiesta such a welcome addition: It’s the only entrant without an overwrought sense of style. No one will call it cute. It’s available in subdued white, black and gray, but you’d be crazy to get this in anything but Race Red. It absolutely looks the business.

The Fiat certainly excels at traffic-dicing on account of its incredible shortness, and it has a 250-pound advantage. However, it’s far less useful as a people and cargo hauler and simply isn’t as quick. The MINI’s steering is more precise and communicative than the Fiesta’s, but it’s more expensive from the start. Plus, options packages can quickly balloon the price to outrageous levels–not to mention the MINI is just 80 pounds lighter than the Ford. The awards for lowest price and best power-to-weight ratio go to the Fiesta.

Inside the Demon

As you’d expect in a budget-friendly hot hatch, some of the interior carries over directly from the previous model. We recognized the dash patterns and door panels, though they wore nicer accents and better materials in areas you actually touch. The Fiesta ST is well equipped and has more standard features than the Focus ST. 

That means navigation with a touchscreen, SYNC voice activation, satellite radio, a leather-wrapped steering wheel and shift knob, and aluminum pedals. There are also ST-branded accents here and there, including headrest embroidery and aluminum doorsill plates. The six-speed manual does everything properly–no automatic is available.

Its only major option is the fantastic part-leather Recaro seats, but it adds nearly $2000. That’s a tough box to tick when the car is only $21,400, but it’s one we’d likely gulp and mark anyway. They’re aggressively bolstered, but also road-trip comfortable–provided you’re narrow enough to fit in them. Stick with the gray cloth inserts rather than the garish bright orange.

The ST’s only demerits–reminders of its roots in the economy-car segment–are for wind and road noise. That could make the car tiresome for long trips on our interstate highways, but at least you’ll get 35 mpg while you bear it.

Ford’s Fiesta ST is well-bred indeed. It brings European flair to American streets, but it actually has much more substance than style. For a commuter vehicle, it’s hard to choose something that’s as quick, fun to drive, stylish and well equipped for this little cash outlay. We’re eager to see them on the road.

Join Free Join our community to easily find more Ford, Fiesta ST, Buyer's Guide and Focus ST articles.
Comments
View comments on the GRM forums
calteg
calteg SuperDork
7/20/23 9:30 a.m.

Everyone I know that's owned a FiST raves about them. The Focus ST seems to live in the shadow of its bigger brother

ConiglioRampante
ConiglioRampante New Reader
7/20/23 11:22 a.m.

Man, I still wish I would have bought a FiST as they were being discontinued in the USA, and Ford was fire-selling them at about $16,000 locally (Austin, TX) and maybe even less once the negotiations began.  What a fun little car.

Ranger50
Ranger50 MegaDork
7/20/23 11:45 a.m.

I have a 19 FiST... it's ok. But it's too damn small for my husky self. Boost is ok, kicks in late. Intercooler is too small.

tb
tb GRM+ Memberand Dork
7/20/23 12:22 p.m.

I just bought a '14 Fiesta ST and am liking it. It wasn't on my radar, but a curious test drive impressed me and I got it well under market rate.

 

I'm big at 6'2" 300lbs and it isn't large, but does feel roomy and solid for an admittedly little car. Already made a few trips to the hardware store with it while I work on maintenance stuff. Perfect 4th car for my wife to learn stick on.

 

My plan is to keep it mostly stock and add in a bunch of safety gear to go racing. Hillclimbs / solo IV / TT stuff mainly but I think it can do anything and be fun. It isn't terribly powerful but is enough and the steering / balance are very good.

 

SKJSS (formerly Klayfish)
SKJSS (formerly Klayfish) PowerDork
7/20/23 12:44 p.m.

This is an old thread, but I'll add my opinion.  I owned a FoST with Ford tune.  It was as fun as a hatch gets.  Razor sharp steering, handles well.  However it had enough shortcomings to make the car not a daily driver for me.  Torque steer was nuts.  Turbo was often "napping".  Huge turning radius.  Tiny fuel tank.  Never seemed to "relax", even when cruising the highway. 

tb
tb GRM+ Memberand Dork
7/20/23 12:57 p.m.

In reply to SKJSS (formerly Klayfish) :

I feel a bunch of what you just said. The FiST also has a 10 gallon tank; I'm told it can be miserly but I don't drive that way. Who does? With less power the torque steer is acceptable and manageable but still present. It certainly doesn't cruise along invisibly at 80 like my other cars.

 

But ford parts are cheap, the stereo is actually decent and I will not lose sleep if I stuff it into the tires. If it was my only car I could happily live with it, but it certainly has shortcomings. 

crankwalk (Forum Supporter)
crankwalk (Forum Supporter) GRM+ Memberand UltraDork
7/21/23 7:59 a.m.

Do these come with a flex fuel sensor and the ability to run E 85 stock?

crankwalk (Forum Supporter)
crankwalk (Forum Supporter) GRM+ Memberand UltraDork
7/21/23 7:59 a.m.

Do these come with a flex fuel sensor and the ability to run E 85 stock?

JoeTR6
JoeTR6 Dork
7/21/23 5:44 p.m.

The gas mileage in my FiST varies from 25 mpg up to 40.  The latter isn't typical, but was from Monument CO to the Denver Airport which is about 2000' of elevation loss and 70 mph.

Mine is a 2017 at 43k miles and has been fantastic.  I've only changed fluids and just getting ready to do brakes.  The only thing otherwise was recently replacing the fuel vapor purge valve.  Easy and relatively cheap.

RacetruckRon
RacetruckRon GRM+ Memberand Dork
7/21/23 6:43 p.m.

In reply to crankwalk (Forum Supporter) :

No the fuel system is limited to an E30 blend unless you upgrade the HPFP and injectors or add auxiliary port injection. 

84FSP
84FSP UberDork
7/21/23 7:14 p.m.

CooperTired's FOST bought from a GRM member was an amazing amount of fun.  He had an e30 tune, bigger intercooler, intake, and a tune.  It was really solid.  With the Recaro interior is was really as nice as the new GTI's inside which surprised me.  

I like but don't fit in the FIST.  Apparently they are far easier to swap a huge turbo onto than the FOST as their turbo isn't integrated into the intake/head.  

My general bitch about everthing Ford of the era was their propensity to not properly paint them and they rust from the edges.  CooperTired's had led a charmed life and was already crusty around the panel edges.

Cooper_Tired
Cooper_Tired HalfDork
7/22/23 7:40 a.m.
84FSP said:

CooperTired's FOST bought from a GRM member was an amazing amount of fun.  He had an e30 tune, bigger intercooler, intake, and a tune.  It was really solid.  With the Recaro interior is was really as nice as the new GTI's inside which surprised me.  

I like but don't fit in the FIST.  Apparently they are far easier to swap a huge turbo onto than the FOST as their turbo isn't integrated into the intake/head.  

My general bitch about everthing Ford of the era was their propensity to not properly paint them and they rust from the edges.  CooperTired's had led a charmed life and was already crusty around the panel edges.

This. 
The FiST is a riot. Begs you to drive like an shiny happy person. But it's too small (to me) to be practical and the seating position was too upright for my tastes. 
Those are the reasons I went with the FoST instead. I loved that car, and it's the only car I regret selling more than my Miata. Quick enough to be a ton of fun with bolt ons and a tune, and it did everything else good enough for me. The turning radius was comically bad, and the fuel tank was a little small, but I could live with that

Shawn Cook
Shawn Cook New Reader
10/19/23 10:57 a.m.

I'm the second owner of a 2016 FoST and love it. It's been a super fun car for me and I've tried to upgrade it with an OEM + approach. The first owner put an Eibach ProKit on it and I think it sits nicely. I wish there was more support/coverage in GRM on these cars as I'm interested in doing more with it. I'm guessing they aren't very competitive for Autocross as I hardly ever seen them featured aside from a handful of Focus RS? If I'm being 100% honest I've actually been losing a little interest in the car because of the lack of popularity aside from the "pops and crackles gang" which I don't relate to at all.. .as proven to myself by cruising with a small group to Caffeine and Octane last week, it just was not my crowd. Maybe I'm turning into an old curmudgeon? (Edited to add a pic!)

 

kevinatfms
kevinatfms GRM+ Memberand HalfDork
10/19/23 12:48 p.m.

Love my FiST.

JMcD
JMcD New Reader
10/19/23 8:40 p.m.

In reply to Shawn Cook :

They've fallen out of SCCA GS favor due to the Civic Si, so that's partly why you don't see as many these days. Go back 5-6 years and they were very popular. I ran a 2014 ST1 for about 6 seasons then decided to move on. Really solid dual purpose car. No complaints other than the brake based e-diff being less than ideal compared to a mechanical lsd.

Shawn Cook
Shawn Cook New Reader
10/21/23 1:25 p.m.

In reply to kevinatfms :

I've been really stuck on FiST over FoST ever since we got a new family daily, a Mazda CX-5. Initially I got the Focus thinking we needed a little more room for road trips but the Mazda is the clear road trip winner every time now. As a FiST owner yourself, what do you like most about it? They do feel a little more unique, plus the worldwide love for Fiesta is a bonus in my opinion.

Shawn Cook
Shawn Cook New Reader
10/21/23 1:25 p.m.

In reply to JMcD :

That makes a lot of sense, I appreciate the context! :)

Snrub
Snrub Dork
10/21/23 3:27 p.m.
Shawn Cook said:

In reply to kevinatfms :

I've been really stuck on FiST over FoST ever since we got a new family daily, a Mazda CX-5. Initially I got the Focus thinking we needed a little more room for road trips but the Mazda is the clear road trip winner every time now. As a FiST owner yourself, what do you like most about it? They do feel a little more unique, plus the worldwide love for Fiesta is a bonus in my opinion.

I find the FiST a great little hauler. We've gotten into this world where we can't seem to do anything without massive space. Over the last couple of years I've hauled loads of hundreds of pounds of wood (1 load was 600lbs a couple months back), furniture, 20 bags of mulch, table saw, gas power power washer, 16' canoe, 16/13' kayaks, it's been packed to the brim with boxes, etc. It's had more hauling use than 90%+ people subject their trucks to. Yes hatch backs are practical, but a lot of the time it's not about the car being insanely practical, it's that I'm not contained by preconceived limitations. Depending on the size of the family and length of trip, I get that a family road trip may be a bit challenging, but there's also something to be said about making due. 

It's a fun, nimble, economic car. You only lose 7hp running 87 octane. Mine weighs 2600lbs (lighter wheels, removed spare, removed rear seats, etc). I suspect I'm going to be keeping it for a decade.

Shawn Cook
Shawn Cook New Reader
10/23/23 12:49 p.m.

In reply to Snrub :

Appreciate the insight! When I say family, it's just me and my wife plus luggage/traveling accessories. We travel from FL to the Blue Ridge Mountains twice a year so the CX-5 with it's ground clearance, extra room, amenities like heated seats etc are why it's the road trip choice. But. totally hear you on hauling stuff as I've done a lot of that with my Focus! I fit 10 bags of quick concrete (500lbs) no prob lol. Day to day trips for me is a mountain bike or a grocery run...and I know the Fiesta can fit those items no problem. cool

kevinatfms
kevinatfms GRM+ Memberand HalfDork
10/24/23 12:49 p.m.
Shawn Cook said:

In reply to kevinatfms :

I've been really stuck on FiST over FoST ever since we got a new family daily, a Mazda CX-5. Initially I got the Focus thinking we needed a little more room for road trips but the Mazda is the clear road trip winner every time now. As a FiST owner yourself, what do you like most about it? They do feel a little more unique, plus the worldwide love for Fiesta is a bonus in my opinion.

I drove EVERYTHING before buying the Fiesta ST. Drove the Focus ST, Beetle Turbo, Sentra SR Turbo, Fiat Abarth. Drove the Fiesta last and it was everything i wanted. 

The Abarth was insane with its exhaust note, also quite zippy but the interior room was a total joke and the seating position felt like driving a dump truck.

Beetle was easily the most refined. But felt way slower than the others i drove and didnt have the fun in the chassis. Also, VW crams everything into the Beetles tiny engine bay. Looked like a total nightmare to work on.

Sentra SR Turbo w/ 6 speed was surprisingly fun and had a ton of communication. The interior was weirdly appointed and there was an odd smell like chemicals im guessing from the off gassing of new plastic? I got a headache and nauseous on a 15min drive with the salesperson. It was my number 4 choice with only the Beetle taking up the rear. 

Focus ST was fantastic. I fit great, had great power, great chassis feel, fantastic interior(Recaros were tight on my thighs though) and it was a Ford so i know it from past working experience. Was getting ready to sign the papers for an ST3 Focus ST when i asked about a few of the Fiesta ST's sitting there. 

2015 Fiesta ST. First drove a Recaro car in Green Envy. Seats did the same thing the Focus Recaros did which pinched my thighs together. Felt uncomfortable. Asked if they had any others without the Recaros. They had one Molten Orange one with base seats but it didnt have the navigation i wanted. So i drove that one to test the base seats out and loved it. Dealer DX'ed an Oxford White w/ base seats, no sunroof with the optional navigation. 

The Fiesta felt way more lively than the Focus. It has this "getting away with murder" flying around town vibe. Feels like you're breaking the law 9 out of 10 times you get into it yet you are still under the speed limit when you look down at the speedo. Its crazy capable out of the box at an autocross and going through traffic is just fun as hell. It had great features with the Sync system and its look fits in with both the "boy racer" crowd and the "GTI is the only option" crowd. Maintenance is super cheap and easy. No big repairs to date on my car with 60k miles. I did install an LSD along with a new clutch somewhere around 55k miles which was a huge improvement in mid corner grip. 

Interior room is great, back of the hatch has enough room for my daily activities and the seats fold down pretty much flat to get big screen TVs in there if you wanted. 

The cons are the stock radiator is a joke, the brakes are undersized for the performance of the car on track and the blend door actuators are made of butter. Everything else is pretty beefy. 

Snrub
Snrub Dork
11/19/23 3:26 p.m.

^ Good points. Sensation of speed and engagement was a bit reason why I bought my FiST. There seems to be a tradeoff between engagement. A little crude, but well executed may be part of what fun cars need to be fun on the street.

Our Preferred Partners
lBIQBYFWaPwNSiHmweRWPlav50DxYwLwPT9bz577egfSYjTPDBJLYMrfe5WkRsVv